Smallflower.comdrugstore.com





Sierra Club


Sierra Club


Welcome & Thank You...

...for visiting the Blog of the Nonviolent Choice Directory.

We feature commentary but most of all action alerts on the same positive, abortion-reducing measures we cover in the Directory.


These measures include post abortion healing; male responsibility; comprehensive sexual/reproductive health education; all voluntary pregnancy prevention methods, plus rape and incest prevention & treatment; and life-affirming ways to get through crisis pregnancy and beyond.

Along with responding to our current action alerts, and participating in our Blog, you are welcome to volunteer with us.






Showing posts with label Progressive ProLifers. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Progressive ProLifers. Show all posts

Monday, May 4, 2009

Progressive Prolifers at the Progressive Magazine's Hundredth Anniversary Bash

(crossposted at Marysia's RHReality Check Diary)

And we weren't gate crashers, either. We were there as part of the festivities, sometimes recognized, sometimes not, sometimes welcomed, sometimes not.

For starters, take two of the speakers on the official program, Congresswoman Marcy Kaptur (D-Ohio) and political scientist Stephen Zunes. Most of the event wasn't about abortion, and these two activists were both present to speak on issues other than abortion (yes, progressive prolifers *really do* care about a whole slew of social justice issues). But their respective stances on that particular subject are a matter of public knowledge.

Anyone with Internet access can look up Marcy Kaptur's legislative record. Including her good record on labor, LGBT rights, family planning, and maternal/child health and welfare, among other recognizable-to-all progressive concerns.

Stephen supports the mission of Consistent Life, an international network of over 200 pro-every life organizations (including Nonviolent Choice). With peace psychologist Rachel MacNair, he co-edited the recent anthology Consistently Opposing Killing: From Abortion to Assisted Suicide, the Death Penalty, and War

Rachel and I are friends who go way, way back and have long histories of our own with Consistent Life. We team-staffed a literature table for CL in the exhibit hall at the Progressive Magazine celebration. Our table featured a large, eye-catching banner: "Prolifers for Peace, Peaceworkers for Life."

And who was the very first person to approach us, when we were still setting the table up? A young man who told us he was prolife, but did not feel free to disclose this opinion in progressive circles. Throughout the day, we met a number of pro-every life women and men who also gladly outed themselves to us.

And quite a few of the people who stopped by were prochoicers who said lovely, hospitable things like, "I may not agree with you about everything, but I'm glad you're here" and "I like your kind of prolife." We had good, respectful dialogues about relieving the root causes of abortion as well as better understanding our areas of disagreement. Including not one but two long conversations with an abortion clinic escort.

Rachel and I enjoyed the overall positive climate of these exchanges. In our long pasts with this sort of thing, we have both routinely experienced some rather difficult difficulties at literature tables. Yes, not everyone of the prochoice persuasion would do this, to be sure...But numerous prochoicers have quite rudely and precipitously mistaken us for some pretty horrid things that just a little polite conversation would quickly reveal us to be decidedly not.

No doubt prochoicers who staff literature tables are also quite familiar with this sort of abruptly unloosed torrent of verbiage that leaves not one unflooded space for response or engagement or self-defense...and it's not much fun, is it?

Although, especially later, it may afford some consolations of comedy. Rachel and I still laugh about the woman who long ago ran up and sternly ordered her, "Stop taking orders from the Pope!" When in fact Rachel is a dedicated Quaker, and the Society of Friends does not even have ministers, for Christ's sake! because that mess is just too durn hierarchical and authoritarian.

We didn't know quite what to expect at the Progressive Magazine event. But not a single person came up to our table and issued one of those dreaded adhominem rants, or scolded us along the lines of "What the hell are *YOU PEOPLE* doing here? Get the f*** out!" Which has also happened, far more than once. That is, when we haven't been excluded before we even had a chance to get in the door...

That's progress among progressives, for real.

Now, a few folks did raise eyebrows at our banner or shake their heads and walk briskly away. And once, when I was by myself at the table, I did distinctly see and hear a pair of conferencegoers stop dead in their tracks, proclaim "Yikes!" and turn aboutface in their tracks...

As if there were not a quite involved and invested sentient being (me!) taking all this in just inches away. And a sentient being at the ready to make eye contact and smile (sincerely, not fakily) at them in passing, at the very least, and if they allowed, to ask them, quite seriously, what specifically was behind that "Yikes!"

I did want to know, I did want to listen, but if people don't give you an opening...But any of these responses sure beat the bad old unreality-based ad hominem rant.

However, something quite troubling did happen to Rachel, after I had taken my leave of the conference and its nonproletarian-priced celebrity fundraising events on my customary posh, high-roller mode of transit, the Greyhound bus.

Rachel attended a bigwig panel discussion on the future of the progressive movement. During the question/comment period, she pointed out the existence of progressive prolifers. She recommended that the progressive movement as a whole work with us to reach people who otherwise might not give progressive values and politics any serious hearing.

Now, Rachel says she wasn't going on any longer, and probably was going on shorter, than others who lined up behind the questioners' mikes. I did attend previous panel discussions, and there sure were a lot of talkative folks with strong opinions who leapt up behind those mikes the instant they were switched on.

But the bigwigs on the panel grumbled that they could see where Rachel was going with this (they could? how did they know before she went there?) There amidst the advocates of free speeach, she was summarily cut off. "Free speech for me but not for thee..."

Then the panel bigwigs unleashed a number of statements Rachel had no chance to publicly respond to. One panel member, for example, criticized the Pope's statements about condoms in Africa--as if "prolife" meant you automatically bowed in obedience to those words, of course.

And no one openly challenged the censorship dynamic here. Indeed, there was apparently a lot of applause for it.

Rachel tells me what else she would have said if her mike had not been cut off:

"I would have responded by re-iterating and bringing [the panelists] back to the point I was actually making about outreach, rather than responding to non-sequiturs. There were several bizarre points made that I could have taken issue with, had I had all afternoon, but I would have kept on track because the session was about the future of the progressive movement and I was keeping on track even if they weren't."

(Now me, I would've explained how those "bizarre points" were nonsequiturs, *then* returned to the matter of outreach. But that's me.)

On the other hand, some women in the audience approached Rachel afterwards and shared their own reproductive challenges. They quickly grasped that hers was not prolife-as-expected, and they all ended up hugging each other.

But why were complex, nuanced, empathetic, very human, small-scale interactions like these--the kinds of exchanges we had both experienced elsewhere in the conference--not reflected in the overt, bigwig-marshalled, publicly unchallenged group dynamics that cut off Rachel's mike?

Like Rachel would tell you if she had half a chance--that question matters to the future of the progressive movement, to the hundred more years we wish the dear old Progressive Magazine.

Friday, March 6, 2009

Prolife Progressives Affirm All Our Lives

Jen Roth of Turn the Clock Forward has just published A Primer on Prolife Progressivism in the progressive online journal Shared Sacrifice.

Great work, Jen!

At the end of Jen's article is an invitation to join a new initiative for prolife progressives, All Our Lives, that is influenced by both the consistent life ethic (secular & interfaith version) and the reproductive justice movement. If this is what you're looking for, as many readers of Nonviolent Choice are--please join in!

Wednesday, November 12, 2008

Nonviolent Choice Shares Its Vision With Change.gov

Turn the Clock Forward is inviting progressive prolifers to share their visions with Barack Obama and his administration through the change.gov website. Nonviolent Choice has taken up the invitation:

Dear President-Elect Obama,

I hope you will make good on your campaign promises and make a real, result-producing effort to bring prolifers and prochoicers together in an effort to alleviate the root causes of abortion.

In developing an action plan to reduce abortion, please call upon those of us who identify as pro *every* life, born and unborn, before, during, and ever after birth. We do exist. In fact, we have existed for centuries, often at the forefront of justicemaking movements of every kind. But US culture has all too often shut out what we have to say, even burying and suppressing our history.

The audacity of hope? I am audacious enough to hope that you and your administration will listen to everything we have to offer on the urgent matter of reducing abortion.

Sincerely,
Mary Krane Derr, Editor
Nonviolent Choice Directory, www.nonviolentchoice.info and nonviolentchoice.blogspot.com
Co-Editor of the book ProLife Feminism Yesterday and Today, Second Expanded Edition (Feminism & Nonviolence Studies Association, 2005)

Monday, November 3, 2008

Want to Volunteer for Nonviolent Choice?

Nonviolent Choice needs volunteers to:

--Adopt a section or subsection of our Directory and check the hyperlinks once a month to make sure they still work. This is no unimportant task. Broken links keep our visitors from getting right to the information and assistance they seek, sometimes while they are in a personal crisis.

--Adopt a section or subsection of our Directory and search the Internet once a month for new or additional resources to nominate for it. We especially need volunteers who are familiar with countries other than the US and languages other than English.

Interested? Please email editor [at] nonviolentchoice [dot] info. Tell us what you would like to do and why. Thank you!

Wednesday, October 22, 2008

Speak Out Against Violence to India's Female Babies

The 50 Million Missing Campaign challenges the rampant sex-selective abortion of baby girls in India. It was founded by Rita Banerji, an ecologist protegee of the internationally renowned Vandana Shiva.

Please sign their petition calling upon the Indian government as well as international human rights and governmental bodies to take substantive action.

Some US prolifers speak of sex-selective abortions as "trivial." As appalling as the abortion of girl-children is, it will never be uprooted and abolished until everyone recognizes that the violence and discrimination faced by women who try to resist it is just as appalling.

Mitu Khurana, a physician from Delhi, publicly stated that she was illegally forced by her physician husband and inlaws into a prenatal sex determination test for the twins she was carrying. When the test revealed that the babies were girls, they pressured and harassed Khurana in an effort to make her abort them.

She courageously refused. As she told the Mumbai Mirror, "I chose to escape and am proud to say that I have given birth to two lovely daughters." The story as well as a beautiful photo of her with her two baby girls can be found here.

What is more, she went public and took legal action against her harassers. Fortunately her own parents have welcomed her back home and are standing right behind her and the little girls. If only more Indian women in this situation could have support in choosing life for their girl children! And even with her own parents' help, Mitu Khurana has been subjected to suffering no one should ever have to face. And how to tell two little girls that apparently some of their own family wanted them dead because they weren't boys?

Saturday, April 12, 2008

You're Invited to Sign Our Manifesto

Nonviolent Choice and Turn the Clock Forward have teamed up to sponsor the following on Care2's The Petition Site. Please join us, and thank you! It is vital that all of us who take such an approach to abortion, women's rights, and reproductive justice stand up and be counted, and (we hope!) to get organized for cooperative action.



Pro Every Life, Pro Woman, Pro Reproductive Justice for All: A Manifesto




Tuesday, December 4, 2007

In Case Anyone Was Wondering.....

I took this online quiz, and now it's official. (:

This is a nice tool for educating people who are afraid of the "f" word.

That's not why I, personally, took it. I embrace the word despite being constantly told that I am the very opposite of one. Just wanted to see what would happen. So this is what happened. I answered all the questions honestly, too.

Although--me, I'd personally take off the boxing gloves and pose with mudras (sacred hand postures) instead.




You Are 100% Feminist



You are a total feminist. This doesn't mean you're a man hater (in fact, you may be a man).

You just think that men and women should be treated equally. It's a simple idea but somehow complicated for the world to put into action.

Friday, July 20, 2007

Prolife, But Not for Dogs?

A story on the current uproar over illegal dogfighting discusses an effort in the US Congress to pass a federal ban on the practice. It includes a revelation of the "please, don't be such a self-defeating stereotype" variety. To wit:

Most of the bill's opponents say they aren't fans of dogfighting but are conservative, pro-life Republicans. Iowa Rep. Steve King from Iowa says it's wrong for the federal government to criminalize pit bull trafficking while allowing legal abortion.

"My vote says that human life needs to be elevated and stay above animal life. And I think it devalues all human life, when you set the life of an animal up above that of a human," King says.


Even if one sets aside the thorny question, too large for a single blog post, on the respective values of human and animal lives...(And by the way, I'm a vegetarian who's adopted three animals from shelters, who writes politicians all the time about animal & environmental concerns, *in concert* with actively opposing abortion....)

Is this not the sort of "either-or," "us-vs.-them," zero-sum approach that turns public deliberation over abortion into the woman-v.-fetus war that derails all efforts to relieve abortion's root causes?

Surely there is a better way to counter abortion than condemning dogs--living, sentient beings, just like any human--to abuse and violent deaths.

This kind of "either-or" thinking obscures a very important reality that need to be addressed in stopping many forms of violence against human beings. Namely, as organizations like American Humane stress, acts of violence towards animals and towards human beings are profoundly interconnected.

Instead of saying "let's not protect dogs, because our government doesn't protect unborn babies," legislators like King could instead say, "let's protect dogs, and maybe that will as well as protecting the dogs, encourage the public to look again at what is done to very small humans."

Sunday, July 8, 2007

Prolife and Prochoice: A Chance to Work Together (Part Two)

Part One of this post series tells the story of Alicja Tysiac. She is a disabled single mother in Poland who struggles to take care of herself and her three children on a state disability pension of 140 Euros/~190 US Dollars per month. Yes, there are people in the world living on much less, but that is a fraction of what the average Pole has to live on, this is still deep poverty, and no person in any country deserves this (let alone less than this).

Whether you are prolife, prochoice, or something else, you can take these concrete, practical steps to help Alicja and her children--as well as other human beings in similarly difficult situations.


1. Send Alicja and her children a financial gift.

--You can do this from many countries through Western Union.
--At the Western Union website, name your recipient as "Alicja Tysiac, Warsaw, Poland" and send your donation in zlotys or PLN.
--Immediately send an email to Elwira Chrusciel, info@astra.org.pl. On behalf of the nongovernmental organization ASTRA, Ms. Chrusciel will notify Alicja of your wired gift. She is also glad to answer any questions you may have about Alicja and her situation.

Note: ASTRA is a prochoice feminist organization; Nonviolent Choice is prolife feminist. But we are glad to cooperate with them on these substantial areas of shared concern.



2. Speak up and act for ALL families in Poland who deal with poverty, disability, and/or single motherhood.

--Write a letter to Roman Giertych, Poland's Deputy Minister and Minister of Education:

Roman Giertych, Ministerstwo Edukacji Narodowej, Al. Szucha 25, 00-918 Warszawa, Poland

(Sorry; couldn't find a fax number or email address. If you have one, by all means, do tell!)

--The proper salutation is "Dear Minister."

--Please make the following points in your letter, politely but firmly.

  • Minister Giertych, even though you disagree with Alicja Tysiac's lawsuit against the Polish government, surely you can understand that she and her children, like any other human beings, deserve far more than the tiny pension they struggle to live on. No one deserves such poverty.
  • All families in Poland who face poverty because of disability, single motherhood, and/or unemployment deserve at the very least a public commitment (in deed, not merely word)to giving them with the Polish equivalent of a "living wage."
  • Minister Giertych, you profess to be prolife. However, does prolife begin at conception and end at birth? Adequate pensions for people like Alicja Tysiac and her family are prolife in at least two ways. They actively express respect for the lives of vulnerable Polish citizens, and in many, many situations, they can relieve the very problems that cause women to consider having abortions.

Note: A future action alert here will take on Giertych's homophobia and hostility to contraception for those whose beliefs permit it. These are also stances that in our opinion equally sabotage his professed commitment to prolife. However, for the time being, a short letter focused on the single issues of adequate pensions is most likely to have an impact.

3. If you are from another country besides Poland: speak up and act for ALL families in your country who deal with poverty, disability, and/or single motherhood.

--Families in these situations everywhere tend to have unnecessary, preventable difficulties, although their precise nature and the amounts and kinds of available social supports can vary from country to country. Try looking through the Nonviolent Choice Directory (direct URL http://www.nonviolentchoice.info)for ideas on how you personally can take other global and local actions.

4. Email this action alert to at least two other people you know!

With thanks for all you can do!

Saturday, June 16, 2007

How to Save 13 Million Human Lives A Year (Part One)

The World Health Organization just released its first ever country-by-country analysis of environmental degradation and its damage to human health and life.

The findings?
  • Environmental improvements could save an estimated 13 million human lives worldwide annually, chiefly but not wholly in the materially poorer nations. (No doubt millions more animal and plant lives could be saved and bettered, too, at the same time.)
  • In some nations, fully one-third of the impact of disease is due to environmental damage.
  • In 23 of the world's poorest countries, over 10% of deaths are caused by polluted, contaminated water and/or indoor air pollution from fuel burning. Most of those who die--74%-- are children under five suffering from diarrhea and/or respiratory ailments. [I know indoor air pollution also disproportionately affects women, and causes a great deal of fetal deaths and injuries.--Marysia] Around the world, children under five are the main victims and make up 74% of deaths due to infectious diarrhea and lower respiratory infections.
  • Even in the wealthiest & environmentally healthiest countries, about 1/6 of what public health experts call the "national disease burden," especially in the areas of cardiovascular disease and traffic accidents, could be prevented through better environmental measures.

What to do?

(My feeling here, as usual, is that there's no point in handwringing as an end in itself; it needs to be a prelude to taking action.)

  • Mass movements of individuals surely do need to shift to more eco-friendly ways of daily living, we all need to each and collectively do our parts this way, especially in the wealthier countries whose overconsumption and greed disproportionately damages the environment among Earth's poor.
  • However, it's both a matter of daily living changes and challenging various socially institutionalized practices that make it slightly inconvenient to difficult to downright finncially and logistically impossible to secure & enjoy the clean, eco-friendly life every creature, including every human being, needs and deserves.

In my next post I will have some practical action ideas.

Friday, June 8, 2007

Are Feminists for Life Really Feminists? Part One

In the January/February 2007 issue of Mother Jones, Emily Bazelon's "Suffragette City" examines whether the avowedly prolife organization Feminists for Life of America can authentically call itself feminist as well.

Bazelon sounds more open-minded and fair than some journalists who have taken on the question, and more power to her for that. But she rests her case on the same problematic conclusions that for decades have staved off the possibility of prochoice feminists engaging with, understanding, and cooperating on common-ground issues with genuine women's rights advocates who oppose abortion.

--She criticizes the group for "its context-free quotes from suffragists. (Anthony and her contemporaries didn't oppose abortion for the reasons that the pro-life movement does today. They considered the procedure a symptom of women's powerlessness, and feared it would blur the line between a 'fallen woman' and a 'lady.')"

--Bazelon finishes with a statement from Frances Kissling, longtime head of Catholics for a Free Choice, regarding FFL's policy/nonpolicy on pregnancy prevention methods: "Feminists for Life want to present themselves as progressive women, whose only interest is protecting women. But when you hear them talk about contraception, it gets weaselly."


I will do my best in some forthcoming posts to address these criticisms. I have been involved in prolife feminist work for over twenty years--including work as a member of Feminists for Life, but on certain points and increasingly a discontent and dissenting member.

Thursday, June 7, 2007

We Welcome The Welcome

Ms. Turn the Clock Forward has graciously welcomed Nonviolent Choice to the blogosphere--and not only that, has encouraged helpful, feedback-giving visitors.

Now how can we argue with a jot or tittle of that?

Not only has at least one person out there noticed us, it's her. She is kewel, check her out. Ms. TCF bravely and diligently started and ran for many the late great email discussion group & website LeftOut: A Haven for Progressive Prolifers.

(and yes, we exist, no, we are not carefully contrived PR smokescreens over rank stealth misogynist-fascist authoritarian-religious agendas let alone the hapless dupes of said agendas, and no, we are not figments of our own purportedly unreality-based imaginations)

And now that blogs are The Thing, she has started a blog that among other virtues unequivocally advocates freedom of choice in family planning, LBGT rights, and comprehensive sex education. How can we not like her?

Hope our other (if any) readers will, too.